Like many film adaptations of novels, Yardie suffers from CliffsNotes syndrome. Idris Elba’s feature directorial debut plows through a steady stream of substantial plot points without providing the narrative tissue necessary to connect events in a manner that gives them a sense of urgency or arches them to an emotional crescendo.
As the film introduces us to 10-year-old Dennis (Antwayne Eccleston) and his older brother, Jerry (Everaldo Creary), the peace-loving Rastafarian DJ whom he idolizes, Elba effectively captures the uniquely contrasting landscapes of 1970s Kingston, Jamaica, from its gang-ridden downtown streets to the lush, seemingly rural spots on the outskirts of the city. But this initial focus on urban ambiance and the inner workings of the clashing gangs is quickly sidelined as Yardie leans increasingly on an over-abundance of heavy-handed storytelling techniques. From the near-incessant voiceover on the soundtrack to hackneyed freeze frames that laboriously introduce each of the film’s major players, Elba bluntly explains everyone’s motivations instead of allowing them to unfurl organically over the course of the narrative.
The film’s tendency to break the “show, don’t tell” directive becomes even more irksome after Jerry is murdered at a concert he organized in order to bridge the gap between the feuding gangs. This event happens so early in Yardie that it’s difficult to grasp how deeply Dennis is affected by Jerry’s death, since we’ve only been given a cursory glance at their relationship. And after its narrative jumps forward 10 years, the film only draws the murkiest of connections between this traumatic event and the older, gang-affiliated Dennis (now played by Aml Ameen). As Ameen’s flat performance gives little additional shading to his character’s emotions, Yardie is left relying on a glut of well-worn conventions, such as Dennis’s frequent visions of his brother silently judging him or brief but extreme outbursts of violence, to unconvincingly convey the inner turmoil that leaves him hell-bent on revenge.
Once Dennis moves to England at the behest of his boss, King Fox (Sheldon Shepherd), he finds himself drawn into the London criminal underworld, which causes an escalating friction between him and his girlfriend (Shantol Jackson), who’s trying to shield their young daughter from the dangers that begin intruding in their lives. Here, Yardie transitions into a tiresome cautionary revenge tale firmly entrenched in the clichés of British crime dramas. And because of its failures to plumb the baffling psychological inconsistencies of Dennis’s behavior, which leads him to repeatedly put loved ones at risk solely for narrative convenience, his quest for vengeance never crystallizes into anything more than aimlessly self-destructive.
Since 2001, we've brought you uncompromising, candid takes on the world of film, music, television, video games, theater, and more. Independently owned and operated publications like Slant have been hit hard in recent years, but we’re committed to keeping our content free and accessible—meaning no paywalls or fees.
If you like what we do, please consider subscribing to our Patreon or making a donation.
