A transitional work for Jacques Rivette, the bridge to the superb Out 1 (and its equally masterful Spectre re-edit), L’Amour Fou relies heavily on its director’s newfound love of improvisation to achieve its aims and effects. The result is a mishmash of ideas and situations both brilliant and inane. A good stateside comparison, created around the same time, is John Cassavetes’s Faces, which, like L’Amour Fou, is a jagged-edge black-and-white psychodrama prone to rather unbelievably grand gestures in constrictively intimate settings.
Were I more of a Rivette-head, I might be able to forgive L’Amour Fou’s frequent lapses into overextended contrivance masquerading as on-the-fly and fly-on-the-wall spontaneity: The numerous switches between 16mm and 35mm footage (anticipating Atom Egoyan, for better and for worse) hint at an aesthetic conversation that never coalesces into anything particularly profound. It is, instead, a series of disconnected actorly moments performed, primarily, by Jean-Pierre Kalfon as playwright Sébastien and Bulle Ogier as his live-in girlfriend, Claire.
L’Amour Fou’s best scenes are its early ones where Claire holes up in the duo’s apartment while Sébastien spends an increasing number of hours at a Paris theater, rehearsing a never-to-be-performed production of Racine’s Andromaque. An extended passage where Claire effectively disappears from the film (only to abruptly resurface as an attempted suicide) as well as a later, incredibly sustained sequence where the lovers exhaust their rekindled passions by destroying the home they both share are two more standout moments among too few.
These scenes are spread thin over the film’s feels-every-minute-of-its-four-hours runtime, and their impact is further dulled by a good bit of nails-on-chalkboard filler (the rehearsals are particularly extraneous, little more than a conceptual dry run for Out 1’s much more insightful examination of performance and how it extends, often violently, beyond the stage). Claire’s hilarious, boredom-laced interlude with a Russian doll is itself an all-too-apt metaphor for L’Amour Fou: much energy exerted for increasingly diminishing and hollow returns.
Since 2001, we've brought you uncompromising, candid takes on the world of film, music, television, video games, theater, and more. Independently owned and operated publications like Slant have been hit hard in recent years, but we’re committed to keeping our content free and accessible—meaning no paywalls or fees.
If you like what we do, please consider subscribing to our Patreon or making a donation.