DVD Review: Hitchcock’s The Lady Vanishes on the Criterion Collection

Hitchcock and film lovers alike should not pass up this worthy copy of one of the director’s British-made masterworks.

The Lady VanishesFor the man who would become the “master of suspense,” Alfred Hitchcock’s 1938 film The Lady Vanishes gets off to a somewhat lumbering start. In a fictional Eastern European country, several British citizens suffer through a long night in a crowded hotel, sharing cramped rooms with maids and tolerating the rousing music of the quaint, multilingual villagers. Though the situation sets up a fateful meeting between playgirl bride-to-be Iris (Margaret Lockwood) and the English rake Gilbert (Michael Redgrave)—as she memorably puts it, “You’re the most contemptible person I’ve ever met in all my life”—little else juices up the first act of the story. Even after Iris boards a train to return to England, befriending the titular old lady who promptly goes missing, Gilbert aids Iris’s search more out of chivalric politeness than concern. A good half the film chugs on by before both realize a more sinister game’s afoot—and the movie is suddenly injected with that good old Hitchcockian suspense.

In less skilled hands, the film’s slow start would be a problem. Thanks to thrilling visuals and an effortless performance by Redgrave, Lady Vanishes is a lively companion piece to Hitchcock’s other magnificent British-made hit, The 39 Steps, about an innocent man mistaken for a spy. Early examples of Hitchcock’s trademarks abound in both films: mistaken identities, match editing, imaginative tight-quarters shooting—including in Lady Vanishes a terrific matte shot of Gilbert hanging out of a train window while another train approaches and blows by. This is to say nothing of an English sense of humor drier than burnt toast: “Find anything?” Gilbert asks the prominent brain surgeon who’s recently operated on a British cabinet minister, to which the doctor replies that he found a small cerebral contusion. “Better than nothing,” Gilbert says. (Somewhere a drummer missed his cue for a ba-dum-chick.)

What separates Lady Vanishes from the more fundamentally Hitchcockian 39 Steps, and makes it more remarkable, is its genuine sense of purpose. The film is a comic satire on British blindness to Germany’s rising threat, standing now as Hitchcock’s cleverest statement on the war. A cover-up is conducted on a train by a string of Germanic nobles, Italian magicians, and Czech spies—yet most of the numerous English passengers have no suspicions. Hitchcock and writers Sidney Gilliat and Frank Launder use more than a few brilliant symbols to reference the English elite’s sense of insularity, such as the sudden appearance of a Holmesian deer hunter hat and pipe at the precise moment the facts of the case need restating. That insularity is turned on its ear through Naunton Wayne and Basil Radford, playing stiff-upper-lip Oxfordians contemptuous of all things un-British, wearing black tie to the crowded hotel restaurant that’s out of food, and so anxious to get back to the final day of a cricket match they refuse to worry about a missing old lady. Even when bullets are flying in the film’s western-style shootout, the British still think of war as a game: Wayne grabs the gun and fires saying he once won a box of cigars. “I’m half inclined to believe there’s a rational explanation for all of this,” he adds.

Hitchcock never places the political ahead of the suspenseful or entertaining aspects of these moments, yet Lady Vanishes is memorable expressly because it feels at times like a statement from an artist fed up with his country’s political uncertainties (within two years of the film’s completion, Hitchcock left England for Hollywood to direct his only Best Picture winner, Rebecca). As such, Hitchcock’s film shines both as the bold technical achievement it was in Britain in 1938 and as a charming and relevant production today.


The disc’s mono sound has a distinctly authentic quality: minor cracks and a residual buzzing that hint at the film’s age. The image is equally suggestive with flickering brightness in certain shots. These slight, even enjoyable flaws place this transfer well ahead previous releases of the widely available film. This disc set is by far the cleanest, brightest release of the 70-year-old film, and another miraculous and worthy restoration by Criterion.


This Criterion set is a two-for-one special, offering John Baxter’s 1941 feature Crook’s Tour on the second disc. Lawrence of Arabia meets Arthur Conan Doyle in a story in which Wayne and Radford reprise their roles as Charters and Caldicott, two British dandies inexplicably stuck in the Middle East. The film is bulky-with a handful of musical interludes and stiff editing-but it pleases in the context of writers Gilliat and Launder’s success in creating the popular comic characters for Hitchcock. Scholars Bruce Eder and Leonard Leff offer insightful analyses of Lady Vanishes on a commentary track and companion video essay, but the real prize of the set is the illustrated excerpts of radio interviews between Hitchcock and Francoise Truffaut, with Hitchcock blasting open the holes in his film’s story. Truffaut gushes over the inventive filmmaking, and both legends come off as kids eagerly raiding cinema’s candy store for every sweet it’s worth.


Hitchcock and film lovers alike should not pass up this worthy copy of one of the director’s British-made masterworks.

 Cast: Margaret Lockwood, Michael Redgrave, Paul Lucas, Dame may Whitty, Cecil Parker, Linden Travers, Naunton Wayne, Basil Radford  Director: Alfred Hitchcock  Screenwriter: Sidney Gilliat, Frank Launder  Distributor: The Criterion Collection  Running Time: 96 min  Rating: NR  Year: 1938  Release Date: November 20, 2007  Buy: Video

Arthur Ryel-Lindsey

Arthur Ryel-Lindsey is a Chicago native who comes correct with an Eagle Scout badge and Ohio State University Marching Band street cred. His writing has appeared in Esquire and The American Interest.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Previous Story

DVD Review: Martha Graham: Dance on Film on the Criterion Collection

Next Story

DVD Review: Mel Gibson’s Braveheart on Paramount Home Entertainment