Connect with us

TV

Review: Survivor Samoa

2.0

Published

on

Survivor Samoa

Stalwart reality series Survivor, now in its 19th season, long ago lost its ability to bring any real surprises into its trademark “the tribe has spoken” ethos, with twists like hidden immunity idols and tribe-member swaps now part of the formula. The show, then, lives and dies by its casting and editing, relying on those two critical components to create the drama that its predictable rhythms and formula now lack. And it’s in those two key areas that Survivor: Samoa is a major letdown from some of the more compelling recent seasons set in Tocantins and China.

In fairness, it’s difficult to say that Samoa‘s casting fails, because so few of the 20 castaways (which is entirely too many to begin with, as a cast this bloated always leaves individual personalities short-changed) have received significant airtime through the show’s first four episodes. Part of that was the result of the Foa Foa tribe’s inability to win any challenges in the early goings of the competition, meaning that the 10 members of the Galu tribe were relegated to the background while Foa Foa plotted and schemed against each other in preparation of voting someone out of the game. But a more significant problem is in the editors’ disproportionate focus on “Little” Russell Hantz, a middle-aged Texan who fancies himself some kind of evil genius, even though his machinations have thus far consisted of little more than emptying his tribemates’ canteens during the middle of the night and outing himself as a misogynist with his constant references to the stupidity of the women on his tribe.

What has made the season such a bore is that the show’s producers and editors—and even two-time Emmy-winning host Jeff Probst—have bought into Hantz’s act, giving the blowhard the opportunity to provide the bulk of the show’s confessionals and talking-head narration. The producers have a vested interest in hyping up Hantz’s strategy, thereby justifying his already Internet-spoiled participation in the show’s upcoming (and, according to recent statements from producer Mark Burnett, supposedly series-ending) Heroes vs. Villains season, where he will be hard-pressed to prove himself more vile or self-delusional than the likes of such luminaries as Tocantins‘s Benjamin “Coach” Wade, Gabon‘s Randy Bailey, or Cook Islands‘s Candice Woodcock.

It’s unfortunate that The Russell Show comes at the expense of one of the most legitimately interesting story arcs the show has ever aired. A show that once infamously divided its contestants into tribes based on race should be one of the last sources of a smart dialogue on race relations, but Samoa‘s third episode hinged on an ultimatum given to the Foa Foa tribe by Jaison Robinson, who insisted that he would walk away from the game if his tribemates refused to vote out the repellant Ben Browning, who had previously directed a great deal of racially-charged invectives toward Yasmin Giles.

Survivor contestants routinely talk about integrity, but it’s exceedingly rare for someone on the show to demonstrate it in action. That Robinson’s comprehensive dressing-down of Browning, whose aggressive ignorance prevented him from understanding any of the larger implications of a Southern white male referring to a black female as “ghetto trash,” at tribal council also gave the show one of the moments of overdue comeuppance and schadenfreude that have long made Survivor a gratifying spectator sport could have provided the season with a real shot in the arm, in addition to a moment of rare insight and grace. Instead, Probst, who attempts to impact the game’s outcome via leading questions and comments more with every passing season, interrupted Robinson’s intelligent, impassioned moment to ask for Hantz’s opinion on the matter.

What has elevated Survivor above the majority of its reality competition brethren are those moments when its social experiment actually pays off, revealing something about how group dynamics evolve or about how individuals can willfully manipulate those around them. When the show focuses on just one or two “characters” like Hantz (or Shannon “Shambo” Waters, an ex-Marine whose frightening mullet and ability to lose the prizes won as rewards dominate what little screen time the Galu tribe receives), it becomes just another indistinct iteration of the type of reality series that it helped spawn. Having lost sight of the game at its core and, instead, emphasizing contestants who are clearly just angling for airtime, Survivor is really starting to show its age.

Cast: Dave Ball, Betsy Bolan, Mike Borassi, Ben Browning, Marisa Calihan, Erik Cardona, Brett Clouser, John Fincher, Yasmin Giles, Russell Hantz, Elizabeth Kim, Laura Morett, Monica Padilla, Jaison Robinson, Kelly Sharbaugh, Russell Swan, Ashley Trainer, Mick Trimming, Shannon Waters, Natalie White Airtime: CBS, Thursdays at 8 p.m. Buy: Amazon

Advertisement
Comments

TV

Review: Amazon’s Hanna Quickly Exhausts the Novelty of Its Premise

The series fails to uphold, subvert, or otherwise comment on the stylistic vision or thematic coherence of its source material.

1.5

Published

on

Hanna
Photo: Amazon Prime

Like the 2011 film upon which it’s based, Amazon’s Hanna follows the eponymous teen (Esme Creed-Miles) as she embarks on a revenge mission against a shadowy spy agency. The series milks visceral thrills from Hanna’s fight skills as she kicks, punches, shoots, and kills burly adult men. But where Joe Wright’s film was distinguished by its thumping Chemical Brothers score, bluntly filmed and brutal action scenes, and strikingly lensed locations, the series neither carves a unique path for itself nor upholds, subverts, or otherwise comments on the stylistic vision or thematic coherence of its source material.

After an opening sequence that sees Hanna’s parents fleeing for their lives from the spy agency, the series flashes forward to regard Hanna training with her ex-military father, Erik (Joel Kinnaman), in the woods where they live in solitude. When the duo is eventually forced to flee their safe haven, Erik reveals to Hanna that he’s actually been preparing her to hunt and kill a villainous C.I.A. agent named Marissa Wiegler (Mireille Enos). While Marissa is shown in flashback to be nefariously connected to Hanna’s childhood, Erik tells Hanna nothing else about her target. Consequently, the central mystery of Hanna’s origin, and Marissa’s role in it, is predicated on the secrets that Erik keeps from her for reasons that are never made clear.

Every episode of the series more or less follows the same format, as slow-burning cloak-and-dagger spy games eventually yield a few more revelations about Hanna’s past before leading to an eruptive and often incoherently filmed climax. The season’s middle stretch is particularly dull, as Erik and Hanna’s first attempt to kill Marissa goes awry and the teen finds herself stranded with a vacationing English family. Hanna attempts to use the relationship which emerges between Hanna and the family’s daughter, Sophie (Rhianne Barreto), to yoke a violent revenge plot to a coming-of-age teenage drama—which doesn’t work, chiefly because it’s impossible to understand why the otherwise unremarkable Sophie would be suddenly obsessed with Hanna, who’s nearly feral and prone to extreme violence.

Of course, Sophie’s fascination with her new friend is mysterious in part because Hanna herself is purposefully difficult to know, with Creed-Miles uses her open face and wide eyes to portray Hanna with a faraway look and a curious intelligence. The girl is inscrutable by Erik’s design, but less understandable is why the adults in the series, particularly Marissa, are similarly vague. Throughout, Hanna goes to great lengths to make its villain, who’s shown committing heinous acts, more sympathetic to the viewer. Certain plot twists suggest that Marissa may be ready to deal with her guilt over the nature of Hanna’s being, yet Enos’s severe, unsmiling performance and the season’s hectic third act go a long way toward muddying our sense of whatever change of heart the woman may be experiencing.

This muddled depiction of Marissa’s ostensible moral transformation, along with the introduction of a cabal of more menacing villains operating alongside her, rob the season finale of catharsis—which is about the only quality otherwise still preserved in the vicious retributions doled out by Hanna. Just as the series struggles to define Marissa’s motivations, it doesn’t hint at what might eventually happen to the rest her shadowy organization. The season’s conclusion asks as many questions as it answers, appearing to exist only so that Hanna may sustain itself, offering more henchman bones for Hanna to snap without wondering whether the character should, or even wants to, keep snapping them.

Cast: Esme Creed-Miles, Mireille Enos, Joel Kinnaman, Khalid Abdalla, Rhianne Barreto, Benno Fürmann, Sam C. Wilson, Félicien Juttner Airtime: Amazon Prime

Continue Reading

Blog

Watch: The Long-Awaited Deadwood Movie Gets Teaser Trailer and Premiere Date

Welcome to fucking Deadwood!

Published

on

Deadwood
Photo: HBO

At long last, we’re finally going to see more of Deadwood. Very soon after the HBO series’s cancellation in 2006, creator David Milch announced that he agreed to produce a pair of two-hour films to tie up the loose ends left after the third season. It’s been a long road since, and after many false starts over the years, production on one standalone film started in fall 2018. And today we have a glorious teaser for the film, which releases on HBO on May 31. Below is the official description of the film:

The Deadwood film follows the indelible characters of the series, who are reunited after ten years to celebrate South Dakota’s statehood. Former rivalries are reignited, alliances are tested and old wounds are reopened, as all are left to navigate the inevitable changes that modernity and time have wrought.

And below is the teaser trailer:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tAcftIUE6MQ

Deadwood: The Movie airs on HBO on May 31.

Continue Reading

TV

Review: What We Do in the Shadows Struggles to Carve Out Its Own Identity

The series struggles to find a distinct voice that isn’t beholden to the original film.

2.5

Published

on

What We Do in the Shadows
Photo: Byron Cohen/FX

Jemaine Clement and Taika Waititi’s 2014 mockumentary What We Do in the Shadows seems like a natural fit for episodic television. The film was somewhat episodic itself, less an ongoing story than loosely arranged chapters of modern vampire life: going out on the town, having virgins over for dinner, dealing with the cops when there are bodies in the basement. For their FX adaptation, Clement and Waititi mostly succeed in translating the film’s comedy into half-hour chunks, albeit sometimes to a fault, as frequent echoes of the film leave the series feeling like it’s still in search of its own identity.

Both the characters and the New York setting of the series are new here, but the setup is the same, with a documentary crew filming the lives of a group of vampire roommates. All of the vampires are hopelessly behind the times, their shared house a dimly lit den adorned with antique furniture, old-timey portraits, and clothing that’s centuries out of fashion. Though the vampires still maintain the otherworldly allure that guides mortals to their demise, vampirism’s sheer flamboyance hardly meshes with the most banal facets of the present day: The local supermarket doesn’t take ancient coins, and one junior member of the Staten Island Borough Council can’t quite hack it as a vampire’s doom-saying herald.

It’s familiar material to be sure, but going back to the film’s bloody well still yields plenty of goofy, memorable personas. Matt Berry’s commanding presence as Laszlo sells the vampire’s oblivious pomposity when he insists on wearing a cursed hat or says something like, “You are a credit to the women’s suffragette movement.” Human servant Guillermo (Harvey Guillén) carries out his grim work with an excitable verve, insisting, “I’m not a killer. I find people who are easy to kill.” At its worst, though, that same familiarity leaves some scenes feeling like they were lifted from the film’s outtakes reel. Certain traits of the film’s characters seem to have been divided among Laszlo, Nandor (Kayvan Novak), and Guillermo, which can lead to the actors seeming to outright channel Waititi and Clement’s performances.

The acerbic Nadja (Natasia Demetriou) adds a more observant dynamic to the general buffoonery of her housemates even as she’s still prone to similar moments of profound silliness, like stalking someone with an old camera that uses a vintage flashbulb. Elsewhere, Colin Robinson (Mark Proksch) emerges as the show’s most memorable creation: a caricature of a milquetoast, nasally desk jockey who’s revealed to be a day-walking psychic energy vampire. Colin, a sentient mound of dull khakis and sweaters, roams the cubicles of his day job, absorbing people’s boredom and irritation, which he amplifies with mind-numbing small talk. When he feeds, his eyes glow and his mouth gapes in an orgasmic snarl that would be frightening if it weren’t hilariously juxtaposed with Colin’s unassuming appearance.

The vampires’ goal is to conquer the “new world” of the United States (or maybe just Staten Island), which opens comic possibilities like a meeting at the aforementioned city council. There are other bits of continuity between episodes, like LARPing enthusiast Jenna’s (Beanie Feldstein) ongoing transformation into a vampire after Nadja took pity on her, but the series isn’t burdened by a serialized plot. For one, the third episode covers a werewolf feud totally unrelated to the group’s fumbling attempts at conquest of America.

Even with such departures, however, these episodes can struggle to find a distinct voice that isn’t beholden to the film. The series certainly offers some amusing additions to this occult universe, but the comedic value of its more familiar material has begun to diminish now that the concept must sustain not only a feature-length movie, but multiple episodes of television.

Cast: Matt Berry, Kayvan Novak, Natasia Demetriou, Harvey Guillén, Mark Proksch, Beanie Feldstein Airtime: FX, Wednesdays, 10 p.m.

Continue Reading
Advertisement

Donate

Slant is reaching more readers than ever, but as online advertising continues to evolve, independently operated publications like ours have struggled to adapt. We're committed to keeping our content free and accessible—meaning no paywalls or subscription fees—so if you like what we do, please consider becoming a Slant patron:

Patreon

You can also make a donation via PayPal.

Giveaways

Advertisement

Newsletter

Advertisement

Preview

Trending