Review: Forgiveness

No one will accuse Ian Gabriel of pushing a glossy commentary about reparations in South Africa, only a shabby melodrama.

Forgiveness
Photo: California Newsreel

Ian Gabriel’s Forgiveness is two films and yet none at all. A man, Tertius Coetzee (Arnold Vosloo), is greeted poorly by a family in Paternoster, a fishing town in South Africa. We learn he killed Magda (Denise Newman) and Henrik’s (Zane Meas) eldest son but the context remains unknown, at least for an hour or so. The filmmakers withhold crucial information from their audience almost as if they were trying to prolong the inevitable. Oblivious to Coetzee, men have been commanded to kill him, and it becomes the sick privilege of Magda and Henrik’s daughter, Sannie (Quanita Adams), and son, Ernest (Christo Davids), to entertain Coetzee’s ambitions until the assassins arrive. As heartfelt as Catch a Fire, Forgiveness plots Coezee’s quest for absolution—just as Phillip Noyce traces Patrick Chamusso’s terrorist uprising—as if it were a 12-step program: He accepts he has a problem, vomits, incurs punishment, does penance, and receives forgiveness. Meanwhile on the highway toward Paternoster, the assassins will lose their cellphones and blame each other for the death of the friend they hope to avenge (one of them, we will also learn, turned the dead Grootboom boy in to the police), which conveniently buys Coetzee the time he needs for Sannie and Ernest to warm to his goodness. No one will accuse Gabriel of pushing a glossy commentary about reparations in South Africa, only a shabby melodrama. Ultimately, the film’s stilted design is more transparent than clever, for which there shouldn’t be any excuse.

Score: 
 Cast: Arnold Vosloo, Zane Meas, Denise Newman, Quanita Adams, Christo Davids, Elton Landrew, Lionel Newton, Hugh Masebenza, Jeremy Crutchley  Director: Ian Gabriel  Screenwriter: Greg Latter  Distributor: California Newsreel  Running Time: 112 min  Rating: NR  Year: 2004

Ed Gonzalez

Ed Gonzalez is the co-founder of Slant Magazine. A member of the New York Film Critics Circle, his writing has appeared in The Village Voice, The Los Angeles Times, and other publications.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.