Connect with us


DVD Review: Edward Yang’s Yi Yi on the Criterion Collection

A one and a two with Yi Yi if you haven’t already.


Yi Yi

Edward Yang’s Yi Yi is a celebration of cultural identity and family interaction. The film’s brilliance emanates equally from its structure (the story is delicately bookended by two cultural rituals: a wedding and a funeral), the acuteness of its gaze, and Yang’s acknowledgement of life as a series of alternately humdrum and catastrophic occurrences, like a flower that blooms in the summer and wilts in the fall; he hopes you will notice it, because seeing is what validates its unique extraordinariness. With the help of his camera, young Yang-Yang (Jonathan Chang) attempts to come to grips with the many dualities of the world around him. He takes pictures of people’s backsides because he wants to show them what they cannot see. His desire is representative of the film’s very philosophy: there is a second side to every story, and the perception of that side promises new awakenings. Yang-Yang’s father NJ (Nien-Jen Wu) must confront the reasons why he abandoned his ex-lover at the altar when they find themselves growing closer again. He acknowledges and frees himself of pent-up pains and admits to still loving her. Though she leaves him this time around, her actions are not vengeful. This transcendent moment suggests that the past cannot be undone and that NJ’s only hope is to improve upon his present. NJ’s cycle of enlightenment ends with the death of his wife’s mother, the family matriarch from whom everyone seemingly draws their every breath. Most appreciative of the old woman’s loving warmth is NJ’s daughter Ting-Ting (Kelly Lee). A flower is the evocative symbol of the girl’s headlong search for inner peace. Her fellow classmates laugh at her for overfeeding it but the wilted plant comes back to life after a divine encounter with her grandmother. It’s a remarkable moment that conveys the transcendence of the flesh and the transmigration of energies between the living and the dead. This is the essence of Yang’s masterpiece, a film whose profound emotional and cultural resonance brings to mind Robert Altman’s Short Cuts.


The difference in image and sound quality between Winstar’s 2001 disc and this new edition from The Criterion Collection is the difference between night and day. The image here seems a tad dark at times, and edge enhancement is a minor problem here and there, but the luxurious color reproduction and impeccable detail will surely advance new and deeper appreciations of the film.


Do not fear the British Tony Rayns, a noted Asian-cinema critic. He is not what The Onion’s A.V. Club might call one of The 15 People You Meet Listening to DVD Audio Commentaries-whom, incidentally, you almost always come across on discs by The Criterion Collection. About as warm as the track Yang recorded for Winstar, this new track is possibly superior by virtue of having a lot less dead spots. This is because Ryans, whose passion for the film is evident, keeps Yang talking-from the anecdotal to his own quaint philosophies of the world and how he tried to filter them into the film-and always on point. Rayns really does know his Asian cinema-for proof, check out his introduction to the film, which is really a snappy summary of the New Taiwan Cinema movement. Also included on the disc: the film’s theatrical trailer and a booklet which includes a predictably passionate article from one of my favorite writers, Kent Jones, and notes from Yang himself about the film, which begins with a lovely reminiscence about a question (“Pourquoi filmez-vous?”) the French newspaper Libération asked him for a special Cannes supplement. His answer, I think, beautifully captures what’s special about the film, and, more personally, makes me feel better about why I like to write about film: “So I don’t have to speak so much.”


A one and a two with Yi Yi if you haven’t already.

Cast: Nianzhen Wu, Elaine Jin, Issey Ogata, Kelly Lee, Jonathan Chang, Xisheng Chen Director: Edward Yang Screenwriter: Edward Yang Distributor: The Criterion Collection Running Time: 173 min Rating: NR Year: 2000 Release Date: July 11, 2006 Buy: Video

“Tell the truth but tell it slant”
Sign up to receive Slant’s latest reviews, interviews, lists, and more, delivered once a week into your inbox.
Invalid email address




Don't miss out!
Invalid email address