J. Cole has spent the better part of his career insisting that true greatness is a product of patience, restraint, and moral clarity. The rapper’s purportedly final album, The Fall-Off marks the inevitable endpoint of that idealistic belief system: a body of work so cautious, so mannerly, and so self-aware that it mistakes adulthood for depth and discipline for risk.
Conceived as a last-ditch attempt to curate the narrative around a not-quite-there legacy, The Fall-Off never collapses outright. But it also fails to take flight, preferring to treat labor as an achievement in and of itself by constantly reminding the listener how long, how arduous, and how seriously its making was.
This self-aggrandizement is nothing new for hip-hop or J. Cole. But his egotism reaches new heights on The Fall-Off, especially since so little here breaks new ground. Over 24 tracks and 100 mostly monotone minutes, Cole lectures on the traps of consumerism (“Quik Stop”), urges humility from others (“Who TF Iz U”), and fumbles through pseudo-philosophical generalities, such as observing on “Lonely at the Top” that it is, indeed, rather lonely at the top.
Cole imagines his life unfolding in reverse order on “The Fall-Off Is Inevitable”—starting with his grandchildren carrying his coffin “to the altar as they burst into tears,” and ending on his mother naming him—to discover what’s Really Important, and not-so-subtly casts 2Pac and Biggie on “What If?” as historical proxies for Kendrick Lamar and Drake. He seems incapable of releasing music outside a meticulously constructed lattice of self-referential callbacks. In other words, he presents The Fall-Off as the closing chapter of a history that, frankly, nobody outside of his core fanbase will understand—a closed loop designed solely to certify its own significance.
The two sides that comprise this double album, titled “Disc 29” and “Disc 39” to signal a hazy division of mindset rather than a clear thematic break, are meant to showcase Cole’s growth over the past decade. But beyond the awkwardly explained-away homophobia on the halfhearted, not-that-enlightened “Safety,” the lack of distinction in flows, performances, and struggle bars only underscores how little Cole has truly evolved. If anything, the album’s bifurcated design is doing far more heavy lifting on this front than Cole himself.
Cole can still tear through a verse with athletic verve, which he does on “Two Six,” and his writing can be technically impressive at times, but outside a few disastrous attempts at singing, the effort on display here is mostly just that: effort. If visible flop-sweat were all that mattered in art, The Fall-Off might be as remarkable as it insists it is.
Since 2001, we've brought you uncompromising, candid takes on the world of film, music, television, video games, theater, and more. Independently owned and operated publications like Slant have been hit hard in recent years, but we’re committed to keeping our content free and accessible—meaning no paywalls or fees.
If you like what we do, please consider subscribing to our Patreon or making a donation.
back to the shite reviews
Needed to be said good review
‘Raymond’ thinks he knows Rap, I’m creasing
Great review!
this MIGHT be the worst review of all time
Think this is bad go look what they gave JID’s last album
Who Gave the Middle class white boy a Rap opinion, stick to Willi Nelson or listening to artists like ‘ratboy’ lmfao, same outlet that gave JID a 40, Raekwon a 50, Lil Wayne a 30 but gave MGK an 80 ahahahahahahahahaahahahaha
stick to suburban white boy pop music Paul.
this is the shittiest review ever made
the only thing this review talked about is the “negative” parts of the album without acknowledging anything good about it, hell, the review only acknowledged 6 damn songs, if you can’t even share opinions on half the songs, you’re not up to review music at all. you can clearly see bias in this review and its absolutely pathetic.