Review: Independencia

Filipino filmmaker Raya Martin confuses broad scope with great depth in his alternate-history fable Independencia.

Independencia
Photo: Volya Films

Filipino filmmaker Raya Martin confuses broad scope with great depth in his alternate-history fable Independencia, which screened earlier this year at Cannes’s Un Certain Regard sidebar. Imitating a crude, early style of in-house studio filmmaking from the ’30s, when filmmakers like Josef Von Sternberg were pushing the limits of the craft of early talkies, Martin re-imagines his country’s history as an elemental humanist epic. Husband and wife travel into the jungle to avoid persecution at the hands of the malicious American invaders, characterized by their oversized moustaches, their guns, and their zeal for infanticide. Martin deliberately moves the story ahead at that level of nuance, mostly forgoing the humor or the visual playfulness that would have earned the film’s unavoidable comparisons to Guy Maddin’s infinitely more personal silent experiments. Martin takes his film so seriously that it makes his sparer-than-spare allegory look like a product of creative constipation instead of thoughtful consideration. Independencia moves ahead at an incremental clip to allow the viewer to luxuriate in the languorous splendor of its characters’ Edenic environ—a clean, artificial place where basic, sturdy, conservative values are fittingly reestablished. Ignoring the circumstances that have led Martin to retreat to this safe new world is one thing, but doing it at such a turgid clip is especially foolhardy as there’s no such thing as a naturalistic fairy tale.

Score: 
 Cast: Sid Lucero, Allesandra de Rossi, Tetchie Agbayani, Mika Aguilos  Director: Raya Martin  Screenwriter: Raya Martin, Ramon Sarmiento  Running Time: 77 min  Rating: NR  Year: 2009

Simon Abrams

Simon Abrams's writing has appeared in The New York Times, Roger Ebert, and The Wrap. He is the author of The Northman: A Call to the Gods.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.