Connect with us


Blu-ray Review: Paweł Pawlikowski’s Cold War on the Criterion Collection

Criterion’s release captures the icy-hot intensity and meticulous beauty of Pawlikowski’s shamelessly grandiose romance.


Cold War

Paweł Pawlikowski’s Cold War—an impassioned, minimalist memorial to the director’s late parents—tracks a torrid romance between Wiktor (Tomasz Kot), a mercurial composer, and Zula (Joanna Kulig), a singer and dancer. The two meet in a small Polish village in 1949, when Wiktor is auditioning local girls for a folk troupe. Zula stands out not because her audition demonstrates a reverence for the folk traditions that the ensemble is meant to promote, but because she transcends them, performing a spirited song from a Russian musical she saw when she was a girl. Wiktor falls in love with her almost instantly, ignoring his assistant’s warning that Zula “apparently killed her father,” and barreling into a relationship that spans 15 years and finds the couple moving apart and reconnecting again in Warsaw, Paris, and Yugoslavia.

As time moves onward, and the sociopolitical identity of Cold War-era Europe changes, so, too, does the music played by Wiktor and his ensemble, from folk to jazz to early rock n’ roll. And Pawlikowski creates a crucial dynamic between Cold War’s two lovers and the burgeoning modernism that surrounds them: Wiktor eagerly changes with the times, while Zula is always a little ahead of them. This leads to Zula repeatedly acting out against him, as she periodically gives up whatever life she’s been leading in various pockets of time spent estranged from Wiktor and comes crashing back into his life, only to find that he can’t quite keep up with her. His jazz isn’t hot enough, and his sexual attitudes are too conservative. But at the same time, no one else comes as close as Wiktor does to pleasing her.

Cold War is shot in the same impeccable black-and-white, full-frame Academy ratio as Pawlikowski’s Ida, but this time the filmmaker engages his symmetrically balanced images as a canvas primed to be disrupted. The various carefully choreographed sequences of the Polish folk ensemble’s song-and-dance performances register almost imperceptibly as anachronistic: Zula’s dancing is just a little more loose-limbed than that of her stagemates, her facial expression a bit more solemn and melancholy as she sings a traditional folk song about a forbidden love. One early shot perfectly encapsulates the film’s vision of nascent, emerging modernity: Zula’s body bobs gently in a river, barely disturbing the water’s surface calm.

Nominally, the film’s lovers are forced apart by authoritarianism. Stalinist ideology exerts its power over great swaths of Europe, causing Wiktor to flee to Paris and become an artist in exile; later, he’s deported from Yugoslavia when his old superiors spot him at one of Zula’s performances. But implicit in Pawlikowski’s streamlined narrative is the feeling that near-cosmic forces are at work in determining the trajectory of Zula and Wiktor’s lives. Another recurring image in the film—a remnant of an old artwork painted in a ruin, of a pair of massive, watchful eyes—seems to seal the fate of these lovers before their affair even begins, and Zula and Wiktor return to the site when their story reaches its conclusion.

Cold War is striking for its precise calibration of narrative minimalism and aesthetic elementalism, and for breaking from the classicist formalism that Ida feels bound to honor. But neither work conveys a great deal of emotional depth: While Cold War’s narrative economy is impressive, it occasionally seems to rein in the expressive potential of Kulig’s phenomenal performance, hurrying through the various episodes of Zula developing a social and cultural awareness and spending a little too much time wallowing with the less interesting Wiktor.

That leaves Cold War most exhilarating as a breathless vessel for mood, one that just so happens to conduct itself within reconstructed period settings that are as obsessively detailed as the reverently curated soundtrack. Just as much care is paid to the spectral spiritualism of old-world Polish folks songs as is to the sensual nightclub scenes where Wiktor plays jazz piano, or the carnal sequence where Zula becomes a whirling dervish when she hears “Rock Around the Clock.” If it’s an otherworldly fatalism that plots Zula and Wiktor’s course through life, their love for each other, so predicated on their obsession with the art that the sociopolitical climate of the time generally represses, distracts them from their oblivion. And while Pawlikowski’s meticulous presentation of their experience with this art doesn’t always translate to an understanding of their inner lives, it still carries an emotive power.


This Criterion Collection’s Blu-ray release of Cold War features a 1080p image track derived from an original 4K master. An impressive level of detail is present in each frame of the film’s frequently long takes, so that Paweł Pawlikowski’s precise framing and Łukasz Żal’s masterful, dynamic cinematography can be fully appreciated. The emotional intensity communicated by the filmmakers’ high-contrast black-and-white imagery is preserved by the disc’s exceptional layering. Likewise impressive is the sound mix, presented in DTS-HD 5.1. The mix facilitates an incredible, enveloping depth in the film’s musical sequences.


A making-of documentary from Polish television gives a sense of how Pawlikowski’s follow-up to his Oscar-winning Ida was anticipated in his native country, and an accompanying behind-the-scenes featurette focuses largely on the extensive training that Joanna Kulig and the actors playing the members of the folk troupe went through. Cold War’s complete press conference from the 2018 Cannes Film Festival, also included here, covers some of the same ground as the making-of featurettes—discussion of Pawel’s inspiration, the work that the actors had to do in preparing for their roles, the complexity of Polish feelings about the communist era—but from the perspective of the Western journalists asking the questions.

A conversation between Pawlikowski and Alejandro González Iñárritu was produced by Criterion for this home-video release. While here, too, certain notes are struck that one will hear again in the other features, the discussion of working methods in this interview goes into quite a bit more depth than in the other videos, given that the two discussants are each accomplished filmmakers. Finally, the disc’s fold-out booklet includes a brief essay by Time film critic Stephanie Zacharek that’s vivid and descriptive, interweaving an appreciation of the film’s visual power with details from Pawlikowski’s biography.


Criterion’s release captures the icy-hot intensity and meticulous beauty of Paweł Pawlikowski’s assuredly stylish and shamelessly grandiose 20th-century romance.

Cast: Joanna Kulig, Tomasz Kot, Borys Szyc, Agata Kulesza, Cédric Kahn, Jeanne Balibar Director: Paweł Pawlikowski Screenwriter: Paweł Pawlikowski Distributor: The Criterion Collection Running Time: 88 min Rating: R Year: 2018 Buy: Video

“Tell the truth but tell it slant”
Sign up to receive Slant’s latest reviews, interviews, lists, and more, delivered once a week into your inbox.
Invalid email address




Don't miss out!
Invalid email address