Yes, we timed the publication of this article, as we do several throughout our Oscar prediction cycle, to get a sense of how guild recognition of a film might point to a larger consensus within the AMPAS rank and file. Yesterday, we were on the fence about whether Roma or Cold War would persevere here. Today, two days after the American Society of Cinematographers handed their top award to Lukasz Zal for his work on Pawel Pawlikowski’s film, we’re still on that fence, if only because ASC isn’t the strongest of Oscar predictors. But Zal’s upset over Alfonso Cuarón may suggest that just enough AMPAS voters think that a victory for the latter, the best director frontrunner, would be redundant.
At this point, we could speculate about the exact magnitude of Cold War’s popularity with the academy, or to what extent fans of Roma feel compelled to vote for the film down the line. But that would not only be redundant of things we’ve already written about both films elsewhere, but boring compared to our need to point out AMPAS’s very bad—and still in-effect—decision to give the nominees in this category the cold shoulder on Oscar night: As of the writing of this article, this award remains among several below-the-line ones that the academy, in a slap in the face to all creatives in the industry, will announce during the Oscar telecast’s commercial breaks. There’s still time for AMPAS to walk back that inexcusable decision. But in case they don’t, here are the nominees for best cinematography:
Lukasz Zal for Cold War…
Robbie Ryan for The Favourite…
Caleb Deschanel for Never Look Away…
Alfonso Cuarón for Roma…
…and Matthew Libatique for A Star Is Born.
Will Win: Cold War
Could Win: Roma
Should Win: Cold War
Since 2001, we've brought you uncompromising, candid takes on the world of film, music, television, video games, theater, and more. Independently owned and operated publications like Slant have been hit hard in recent years, but we’re committed to keeping our content free and accessible—meaning no paywalls or fees.
If you like what we do, please consider subscribing to our Patreon or making a donation.
