Here We Go Magic A Different Ship

Here We Go Magic A Different Ship

2.5 out of 52.5 out of 52.5 out of 52.5 out of 52.5 out of 52.5

Comments Comments (0)

For DIY recording artists, the appeal of making music in your bedroom goes beyond the obvious budgetary considerations. At its very core, the lo-fi aesthetic is invaluable in setting a greater mood: The raw, atmosphere-heavy result of using tape-cassette recorders and intentional quality degradation can evoke an intimacy and allure few lyrics or instrumentation could ever achieve. It’s the reason Ernest Greene’s Within and Without, steeped in multiple layers of worn, analog-fueled idiosyncrasies, remains a master class in how to bolster melody with mood.

That same purposeful approach to coarse, no-frills recording elevated bare simplicity into haunting elegance on Here We Go Magic’s The January EP. On tracks like “Hollywood,” a three-note acoustic refrain is quite literally electrified with crosswire noise and the faint humming of cheap machinery. The buzzing is hardly random, but instead serves as a textural counterpoint to the warmth of the song’s folksy guitar and choral parts; without it, “Hollywood” is rather benign.

Which is, unfortunately, a rather appropriate word to describe the Brooklyn band’s maddening third full-length release, A Different Ship, in which they dilute the cerebral lo-fi so adequately rendered on The January EP in favor of play-it-straight, predictable baroque pop and relegate their obvious strengths to mere collateral. That’s not to say that what results is unlistenable: Tracks like “How Do I Know” capture a troubadour-like charm from the clean, acoustic indie pop that Here We Go Magic has suddenly embraced. “How do I know if I love you, when all these things come and go?” leadman Luke Temple croons over the light, steady beat, a vocal-and-percussion combination that reappears on similar easy listeners like the title track and “Over the Ocean.”

Pleasant, paint-by-numbers pop tends to wear, however, and the album’s shelf life is likewise diminished by immobile clunkers like “Made to be Old” and “I Believe in Action,” both of which play like the band is slowly emerging from an Alien-style cryogenic hibernation. A song like “Alone But Moving” perfectly encapsulates the sleepiness that plagues the album as a whole, drifting in a lull between its lazy, synthetic drones and a rather predictable, painfully sluggish chord structure. With A Different Ship, Here We Go Magic has essentially removed the “psych” from psych-folk and replaced it with monotony.

Release Date
May 8, 2012
Secretly Canadian