The 25 Best Music Videos of 2011

by Slant Staff on December 21, 2011   Jump to Comments (12) or Add Your Own


10. Gotye featuring Kimbra, "Somebody That I Used to Know" (Director: Natasha Pincus). A passionate pas de deux in which Gotye and Kimbra passionately hurl misgivings at each other for what they once had is accompanied by an equally remarkable video, a work of lovely simplicity that expresses the coming together of two lovers as a literally prismatic tug of war. As naked as their emotions, Gotye and Kimbra suck each other in with their embittered recollections of happiness and sadness before one of them, sadly but wisely, chooses to move on. EG



9. Youth Lagoon, "Montana" (Director: Tyler T. Williams). In which director Tyler T. Williams channels Terrence Malick to depict a depleted man-child escaping (however poorly) the shadow of childhood tragedy. A familiar, heavy hand with the Americana, yes, but gorgeous all the same. KL



8. Lana Del Rey, "Video Games" (Director: Lana Del Rey). This is a song about sacrifice, the things a girl will do for the love of a boy, and Lana Del Rey uses its dreamy video not just to sell her brand of Hollywood sadcore, but to provocatively ruminate on the Dream Factory's callous exploitation of aspiring starlets, even expert self-promoters like herself and the hot mess that is Paz de la Huerta. No wonder David Lynch fell in love with Del Rey. EG



7. Manchester Orchestra, "Simple Math" (Director: Daniels). The only video on this list that breaks my heart, a poignant, almost Gondrian conceptualization of a man's life flashing before his eyes that articulates its ideas of love, anger, regret, and disappointment sans the quirkiness that typifies Gondry's signature surrealism. After swerving his van to avoid a deer, a man spirals toward death, remembering his contentious relationship to his father, even the deer he once shot and whose head he awkwardly gifted to a girl who didn't return his affections. Through its appropriately blunt use symbols, of objects fusing different planes of reality into one, this Daniels-directed clip sadly, almost disturbingly equates dying to dreaming. EG



6. Rihanna, "We Found Love" (Director: Melina Matsoukas). Calvin Harris's Ibiza beats are enhanced by a series of striking, hazily filtered Technicolor images of his Barbadian muse and her fictional boy toy frolicking in a bathtub, popping pills, smoking rainbows, and vomiting streamers. Melina Matsoukas's video projects (literally and figuratively) the fleeting rush of both young love and drugs—and the often fatal cocktail that's produced when the two are combined. SC



5. R.E.M., "ÜBerlin" (Director: Sam Taylor-Wood). An unsurprising omission from Pitchfork's embarrassing "Top Music Videos [That Caught Our Eye]" and NME's more respectable but equally single-minded "50 Best Music Videos of 2011 [w/ Hot Girls, Read: Not Lady Gaga, in Them]," R.E.M.'s "ÜBerlin" easily wrestles the Best Dancing By Yourself Video of 2011 prize from Robyn's "Call Your Girlfriend." Starring Aaron Johnson and helmed by the actor's Nowhere Boy director, Sam-Taylor Wood, the video perfectly captures the optimistic spirit of what may be R.E.M.'s last great song, a lush, euphoric, and, most important of all, irony-free celebration of street and life. EG



4. Battles featuring Gary Numan, "My Machines" (Director: Daniels). Common symptoms of Escalaphobia include nausea, increased heart rate, dizziness, visible trembling, and an overwhelming compulsion to listen to math rock. SC



3. Tyler, the Creator, "Yonkers" (Director: Wolf Haley). With typical I-don't-give-a-shit-ness, Tyler makes himself the target of this particular litany of gripes, essentially a series of paradoxes so Joycean in their density they could stand to have their own set of Cliffs Notes. Take this black-and-white clip as an expression of how Tyler sees himself in constant war with himself, or as a wry, perverse acknowledgement on his part that the best, maybe only, way of making sense of his sick rhymes is by overdosing on bug juice. EG



2. Lady Gaga, "Born This Way" (Director: Nick Knight). You won't see a more striking visual this year than the first 30 seconds of Lady Gaga's "Born This Way," where a sparkly unicorn and hot-pink laser triangles give way to the artist's 21st-century portrayal of Metropolis's Maschinenmensch. Perhaps more impressive, however, is that the video's ensuing shots manage to be just as provocative: glistening kaleidoscope gore, hermaphroditic machine-gun phalluses, black-tie zombies, and a literal human melting pot that plays out like something dreamed up by a gloriously unholy matrimony of Alejandro Jodorowsky, Zack Snyder, and H.R. Giger. KL

= =


1. Is Tropical, "The Greeks" (Director: Megaforce). Satirical commentary on society's obsession with gratuitous violence, or child exploitation in the form of reverse infantilism? Either way, French collective Megaforce's clip for Is Tropicals's "The Greeks" is both the funniest and most explosive music video of the year, a celebration of the imaginations of boys who only slow down for a rotisserie chicken and some mashed potatoes. SC



Page 3 of 3

Page:  «  prev  1 2 3



Comments

Kinetos on December 21, 2011, 10:21 AM

i would have love to read the reasons wby "Born this way" is your #2 in the best video of the year. You manage to say that it's provocative, but is there any point to all that provocation? Don't get me wrong, i wished I loved "Born This Way" as much as "The Fame: Monster", but the videos are plain egocentrical and alter-ego-driven, which is too much for me, and not enough at the same time, because it doesn't make any sense. It seems that she lost all her spirit and soul, and that she is just a wannabe of herself.

And in all that crap of a visual that she builds in that video, she lost the meaning of the community she's supposed to be endorsing. Just saying!

Ed Gonzalez on December 21, 2011, 12:13 PM

Kinetos, I have a confession. Of the three contributors to this list, I was the one who ranked this video the lowest, though it did still place within my Top 10. I do think it pretty much dies a slow, albeit still-fierce death, once the song starts, but that intro is just about the most brilliant thing Lady Gaga has produced to date. She references throughout a legacy of avant-garde images to very much lay out her "Mother Monster" manifesto, to push out (literally and figuratively) an origin story (not unlike the origin stories in the works she may or may not be referencing here, from Kenneth Anger's Lucifer Rising to Superman II) to very much posit herself as the universal mother to a new breed of freaks. I would say that her eye never stops looking at that community you feel she's lost sight of.

BloodyChapel on December 21, 2011, 03:01 PM

I'd love for you to explain what you mean by "she lost all her spirit and soul, and that she is just a wannabe of herself." Cause honestly, it doesn't make sense, at all .

Mike321 on December 21, 2011, 10:26 PM

Good for you, Ed. Defend your mother monster.

Way to earn that pay check.

Mike321 on December 21, 2011, 10:41 PM

I kid, I kid.

To be honest, Gaga deserved a spot in the top 5 of this list. But I'd replace "Born This Way" with "Marry the Night". That's an amazing video.

PS: what makes a great video? Because as much as people scoff at it, I think "Rolling in the Deep" is an amazing video: so layered, so symbolic, so ambiguous. And it suited the lyrics well:

The song is about Adele's lover leaving her, and she laments how they could have had it all etc etc etc. The video shows her sitting all by herself in a dimly lit room in a large, broken-down, old house— this signifies loneliness, desertion and abandonment. Her sitting down symbolizes hopelessness and despair (her movement is intentionally confined; there's nothing she can do about the situation; she's given up). The abandoned house and dilapidated furniture symbolize things that could have been; broken dreams, a broken home. We see dishes breaking— this symbolizes anger, rage; but the amount of dishes symbolize the serious, almost apocalyptic nature of her situation (an idea that is strengthened with the burning city at the video climax). Water symbolizes calmness and tranquility. In an interview, she said the beat of the drum in the song symbolized her racing heartbeat. As the drum beats in the video, the water begins to jerk and ripple with the rhythm of the drum, suggesting increased agitation, emotional disturbances. And I could go on and on and on.

Yet, you all choose to applaud Gaga's space opera nonsense. You guys will write a 1000 word analysis of "Edge of Glory", but won't try to find the layered meanings in Adele's avant grade masterpiece. It's not all about spectacle, Slant.

HerMadgesty on December 21, 2011, 11:42 PM

you're right Mike, it's not all about spectacle. And the majority of the videos on this list have nothing to do with spectacle. I think you should seek help for your Gaga obsession!

p.s. Wasn't "Rolling In The Deep" from 2010?

Grotesk on December 22, 2011, 03:28 AM

Fail Adele stan failed.

ouch. haha.

Ed Gonzalez on December 22, 2011, 09:48 AM

Mike, if you want to write about music videos for the site please contact Sal as sal@slantmagazine.com. Incidentally, I voted for the Rolling in the Deep video for this poll and don't write about music videos for the site outside of these lists, so you can spare me the lecture.

Mike321 on December 26, 2011, 01:45 AM

Ed, my second message was never aimed at you, so yeah. You're spared from my lecture. I don't think I could change you people from your gaga worshipping ways, nor do I want to.

And to HerMadgesty, "Rolling in the Deep" was released in December 2010, which means that it made its impact in 2011 and would be considered within lists for 2011 (It's not like it's going to be released in December and make it onto a year-end best-of list in a week).

And to Grotesk, I'm not an "Adele stan". I don't believe in those catty labels used by u gay guys. And say what you want, but Adele is having the year Gaga can only dream of having. and when she wins her 6 Grammys next year, Gaga will be sitting in the audience, crying in her egg.

jaknight2 on December 27, 2011, 04:21 PM

Wow, Mike321, talk about catty. Just re-read your last statement above; it pretty much lumps you in with "[us] gay guys."

No-Personality on December 29, 2011, 03:03 PM

I completely agree with Kinetos.

Oh, and that Zack Snyder's name found itself anywhere in this article, makes me want to see him disappear even more!

lyrafowlpotter on May 22, 2012, 03:16 AM

LOL @ Mike, you were right about her 6 grammys! Not sure Gaga was crying in an egg, but I bet all her aggressive blood rituals were targeted at Adele... ;P

Add Your Own

Login to post comment

or Create an Account



Giveaway

A Bullet for the General Blu-ray
Newsletter