Heroes is now a quarter of the way into its second season, but its sixth episode “The Line” is evident of the lack of progress the show has made since returning in September. The vast (and ever-expanding) ensemble remains scattered to the winds, their various plots lumbering sluggishly towards recycled conclusions. The cliffhanger at the end of “The Line” finally hints at a possible unifying save-the-world arc for the show to rally around—just the thing Heroes needs to regain its zeitgeist credibility. The problem is, the cliffhanger is a lame rip-off of the show’s own material, which just serves to hit home how this season has been a rather pale imitation of the first.
After all, the first season at least had the element of surprise. There were plenty of shocks, most of them character-related, for the writers to reveal. Nathan can fly! Peter absorbs powers! Sylar steals powers! And so on. By now, that’s obviously no longer an option, so we’re treated to far more ordinary plot developments, like Peter’s amnesia, Claire’s suspicious boyfriend, Parkman’s father being evil. Even worse, some of the new characters demonstrate powers we’ve already seen before—Kensei can regenerate like Claire, West can fly like Nathan, and Monica’s ’muscle memory’ bears similarity to the quick learning skills of last year’s recurring character Charlie (Jayma Mays). I’m not ready to give up on Heroes, partly because I think it’s eventually going to pick up speed out of sheer necessity. Nonetheless “The Line” (written by Adam Armus and Kay Foster and directed by Jeannot Szwarc) is another meandering, at times frustratingly dull hour, redeemed only by a similar theme running through all of this week’s stories.