The only film I managed to see on Day 4 was Woody Allen’s Vicky Cristina Barcelona, a long-form review of which should be posted soon. Hint: It’s awesome.
Serbis (Brillante Mendoza). I pulled my first D’Angelo of the festival by walking out of this miserable slog, which has been racking up the most universally vicious reviews of the festival. Set in a family-run porno theater in the Philippines, the film wants to be a chronicle of the difficulty of living in the run-down alleys and backstreets of Asia. But instead of creating any sort of social or political context, Mendoza instead resorts to self-consciously shocking imagery and pointless, unremitting ugliness. I bailed soon after an explicit sex scene that culminated with the man changing positions so as to not irritate the giant, pus-filled boil on his ass. Reportedly, the timing of my exodus allowed me to just barely miss the first of several extended scenes of unsimulated fellatio between two of the male hustlers that frequent the theater. Lucky break, I think.
Lorna’s Silence (Jean-Pierre Dardenne and Luc Dardenne). The Dardenne brothers continue their remarkable streak of films with their follow-up to 2005’s Palme d’Or winner L’Enfant. Reviews for the new film have so far been somewhat lukewarm, which does not strike me as surprising; when you follow a near-masterpiece with a film that’s “only” really good, there will inevitably be some backlash.
It is true, admittedly, that Le Silence de Lorna is not as strong as L’Enfant (or La Promesse or The Son, for that matter; I haven’t seen Rosetta). The reason may be that Le Silence de Lorna is the brothers’ most plot-driven film to date. The simplistic narratives of their previous films allowed for spare, spiritually pure examinations of various moral issues. Le Silence de Lorna has a more contrived narrative trajectory; Lorna (Arta Dobroshi), an Albanian immigrant to Belgium, marries a heroin addict named Claudy (Jérémie Renier) in order to gain citizenship. The plan is to eventually murder the junkie by faking an overdose so that Lorna can then marry a wealthy Russian man who seeks citizenship. When Lorna attempts to avoid murdering Claudy by procuring a hasty divorce, the Russian’s associates are not pleased, and Lorna feels so much guilt over the result that she suffers a sort of mental break.
The first hour of Le Silence de Lorna follows in the same naturalistic footsteps of the brothers’ previous works, as it observes the day-to-day life of Lorna and Claudy and Lorna’s attempts to help Claudy get clean. The turn that the narrative eventually takes, while subtly and gracefully executed, yanks the film out of the realm of real life and into that of movie-world fiction. It’s not a disastrous move, but L’Enfant and The Son were so unbearably moving precisely because their stories of guilt and redemption were so grounded in reality. With Le Silence de Lorna, the Dardennes have become victims of their own greatness. For any other directors, it would be a triumph; for them, it’s a slight step back.
Two Lovers (James Gray). I am in the distinct minority on this one, Gray’s followup to last year’s We Own the Night, a standard-issue crime melodrama made interesting by Gray’s stunning visual sense and emotional sincerity. The same goes for Two Lovers, a melodramatic relationship drama that succeeds on the strength of Gray’s images and romantic earnestness.
The film stars Joaquin Phoenix as Leonard, a troubled man living with his parents after another failed suicide attempt. Phoenix plays Leonard as a good-hearted but possibly slightly autistic romantic, a photographer torn between relationships with the unexciting but loving Sandra (Vinessa Shaw), the daughter of his father’s business partner, and his unpredictable but emotionally damaged neighbor Michelle (Gwyneth Paltrow). Gray explores these two relationships with obvious and over-heated dialogue, but his images are anything but standard.
Gray shoots night-time in the city as well as any director this side of Michael Mann, and his glittering, forceful compositions carry a great deal of emotional heft. One scene between Phoenix and Paltrow is shot on the roof of an apartment building, with the doorways of a roof-top shed framing the actors as Gray moves his camera gracefully around the building. Gray’s has some antiquated ideas about romance, but he means them, and his narrative’s ultimate trajectory gets at some fundamental issues surrounding human love. The film’s final scene, which has been grossly misinterpreted by some as falsely sunny, is a near-devastating balance between happiness and uncertainty.
Two Lovers is not a great film; it’s not even close. But it confirms Gray as, I think, one of the most exciting new directors to come out of Hollywood. He’s not making movies quite like anyone else around, but whether that’s a good thing or a bad thing depends on who you ask. If you ask me, it’s a very good thing indeed.
Matt Noller lives and studies film and journalism in Athens, Georgia. You can also read him at Uh, movies.