Review: Bloody Sunday

The film’s ultra-realism echoes Welcome to Sarajevo, except Paul Greengrass wrings more naturalistic performances from his actors.

Bloody Sunday
Photo: Paramount Classics

Some 30 years after the January 30, 1972 Derry massacre in Northern Ireland, the Parachute Regiment are still spin-doctoring the events of that day. Though hoping to end unionist rule in Northern Ireland through non-violent means, hundreds of civil rights activists were fired upon by British soldiers who later claimed they were only responding to IRA gunfire. The day later became known as Bloody Sunday, a major cause for the cycle of violence that would plague the area for decades to come. That director Paul Greengrass’s gripping Bloody Sunday could easily pass for a documentary on the subject is a testament to the immediacy of this vérité exercise. Greengrass offers little historical context for the events of Bloody Sunday beyond a series of intertitles that close the film. Understandably, the film has courted controversy in merry England, and while Greengrass clearly sides with the Irish peacemakers, his humanism affords compassion for confused Parachute troops that may or may not have been incited to violence because of the ineffectual chain of command between the field and the British Army’s headquarters. A promising formalist, Greengrass cuts between scenes with hyperbolic fadeouts that have a way of displacing the events depicted in the film into memory. The film’s details are rich yet subtle (a local theater in Derry plays two films: The Magnificent Seven and Sunday Bloody Sunday) and the sense of dread is overwhelming. Greenway seemingly suggests that non-violent resistance is possible only if we trust in each other’s promise not to bear arms. When the people of Derry begin to throw bricks at British soldiers, there’s a sense that Bloody Sunday would not have happened had the British not doubted the human rights league’s promise to march peacefully through the town. The film’s ultra-realism echoes Michael Winterbottom’s polemical Welcome to Sarajevo, except Greengrass wrings more naturalistic performances from his actors; as Protestant peacekeeper Ivan Cooper, a brilliant James Nesbitt is every bit as frazzled by constantly buzzing phone-lines as he is by the bullets that kill his countrymen.

Score: 
 Cast: James Nesbitt, Tim Pigott-Smith, Nicholas Farrell, Gerard McSorley, Kathy Keira Clarke, Allan Gildea, Mary Moulds, Carmel McCallion  Director: Paul Greengrass  Screenwriter: Paul Greengrass  Distributor: Paramount Classics  Running Time: 105 min  Rating: R  Year: 2002  Buy: Video

Ed Gonzalez

Ed Gonzalez is the co-founder of Slant Magazine. A member of the New York Film Critics Circle, his writing has appeared in The Village Voice, The Los Angeles Times, and other publications.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.