The Killing

The Killing

4.5 out of 54.5 out of 54.5 out of 54.5 out of 54.5 out of 54.5

Comments Comments (0)

Every split second counts at the racetrack, where fortunes are won and lost in as much time and the smallest decisions carry a built-in intensity few other locations can claim. The Killing, a blisteringly taut decimation of post-WWII entitlement, understands this better than any other crime film. Stanley Kubrick’s 84-minute jigsaw puzzle transports the dancing moral contortions of film noir to the pressure-cooker atmosphere of the track, infusing them together with dread-inducing temporal uncertainty. This story of low-level hoods and unlikely schemers planning to rob a Los Angeles racetrack condenses the moment-to-moment plotting typical to the heist movie, revealing a nonlinear, fractured narrative seething with anger.

Like a splash of cold water to the face, Kubrick institutes a dry, almost clinical voiceover to chart the progress of the robbery, introducing each man’s hidden reasons for letting their freedom ride. The sobering audible device echoes Dragnet in all the right ways, speaking in past tense as if these men were ghosts foolishly trying to change what has already been predetermined. Johnny Clay (Sterling Hayden), just released from a five-year stint in prison, instigates the operation, recruiting inside men from the track like bartender Mike O’Reilly (Joe Sawyer), bookkeeper Marvin Unger (Jay C. Flippen), and clerk George Peatty (Elisha Cook), along with corrupt policeman Randy Kennan (Ted DeCorsia), to orchestrate the daring heist. Each represents a specific role in the intricate process, a key piece to the overall puzzle. How they fit together and break apart becomes Kubrick’s core interest.

The men of The Killing all believe their newly acquired riches will salvage whatever opportunities they’ve previously squandered. Johnny needs the cash to run away with his innocent lover, Fay (Coleen Gray), and the motif continues down the line; Marvin wants to sustain a strange paternal relationship with Johnny, Mike hopes to cure his sickly wife, and Randy intends to free himself from a brutal loan shark. But it’s the weak-willed George who becomes the final straw on the camel’s back. George naïvely believes the money will satisfy his wide-eyed viper of a wife, Sherry (Marie Windsor). Her passive-aggressive interrogations are ripe with assaults on George’s nonexistent masculinity, and what begins as idle pillow talk quickly avalanches into full-blown disaster.

In the heist film, any one character’s faith in the group can dissolve in favor of self-survival at a moment’s notice. Early on, Randy even warns, “I’ll take care of myself. That’s my specialty.” And as the mistakes pile up, making a once carefully modulated plan on paper turn to dust, The Killing constantly threatens to fulfill such genre conventions. But Kubrick withholds the expectation of capture, betrayal, or death until the last possible moment, stretching out Jim Thompson’s bullying and brilliant dialogue sequences, juxtaposing them with hypnotically fluid long takes through clogged interior spaces. These precise visual aesthetics suddenly explode with violence, best exemplified in the moment thuggish Maurice (Kola Kwariani) stages a planned brawl in the track common area, taking on a platoon of cops in the process, or when Johnny watches sniper Nikki Arcane (Timothy Care) shred a paper target with automatic shotgun fire. Violent uncertainty like this infects every corner of the frame.

Lucien Ballard’s glorious shadow-play cinematography helps Kubrick further manipulate space through layers of texture, using angular key lighting to pin spotlights on each character’s fatal flaws. Johnny’s overconfidence during a roundtable planning session, George’s easily manipulated rationale, and Sherry’s tragic underestimations of George, all resonate because of their gripping noir environments. The robbery itself feels like a cinematic summation of Kubrick’s Kino-nastiness. Set inside the cavernous maze of the racetrack infrastructure, it’s a nearly wordless and always gripping example of narrative misdirection. Johnny dons a clown mask, pulls a shotgun out of a flower box, and patiently waits for a moment to pounce; his house of cards seems set up perfectly for success. But the scales quickly tip against him, and the sequence becomes a panicked sprint to the finish line, much like the horse race unfolding in the background. The track announcer’s play-by-play makes for a fitting and instinctual parallel to his breakneck smash and grab.

Underneath The Killing’s clockwork violence is a pungent layer of irony, something Kubrick would further explore many times later in his career. A vicious symbolism connects disintegrating artificial surfaces and mortally wounded characters, a motif that comes to fruition when George stumbles out of Johnny’s apartment late in the film, his face pockmarked with buck shot horrifically personifying the aforementioned paper target. Kubrick’s wicked brand of jet-black irony takes many other forms (Sherry’s parrot squawking loudly during her death knell is especially potent). But it’s the final image of an ocean of cash blowing in the wind that best echoes the uncontrollable and unseen machinations working against these desperate men. Despite a collective hope for the future, they will always be puppets, no matter how hard each tries to cut the strings of fate. Screw Murphy’s Law; this is Kubrick’s Law, and no one makes it out unscathed.


The release of The Killing on Blu-ray is a special occasion. There have been rumblings about its release on the Criterion label for years, and the disc's crystalline 1080p transfer proves the wait was entirely worth it. Lucien Ballard's sterling noir imagery crackles with layers of shadow and light, aesthetics visually dulled in previous DVD transfers. The black levels in the night sequences are especially moody and clear, the best example coming when Johnny talks with his crew at the table in his apartment. Illuminated overhead by only a key bulb, Johnny sways in and out of the shadows as if he was dancing between heaven and hell, and the viewer is privy to every visual detail. In terms of sound design, The Killing beautifully mixes quieter dialogue moments with sudden booms of chaos, and the uncompressed mono soundtrack nicely exhibits this audible juxtaposition of opposites.


As if having The Killing on Blu-ray wasn't enough, Criterion has included a new hi-def transfer of Kubrick's previous feature, 1955's Killer's Kiss. Film critic Geoffrey O'Brien provides a great video appreciation of the film, stating that "the accidental comes into play more" in Killer's Kiss than any other Kubrick film. A chorus line of interviews with key Kubrick collaborators and scholars are also included. Producer James B. Harris talks extensively about his storied partnership with Kubrick, the production process of The Killing, and most interestingly Kubrick's love and talent for casting character actors in lead roles. A grizzled Sterling Hayden talks about his tumultuous time in Hollywood in a 1984 interview for French television series, Cinema Cinemas. "In no other business can you get paid good money and not know what you're doing," Hayden laughingly confesses about his early acting years, the solace of the San Francisco Bay providing a calm background for his gruff façade. Finally, author Robert Polito discusses the factors behind crime novelist Jim Thompson's involvement in The Killing, citing Kubrick's desire to improve the dialogue in his pictures. Like all the interviews on this great supplemental package, Polito waxes eloquently and analytically at the same time. Trailers for The Killing and Killer's Kiss round out the lineup. The booklet is one of the lighter editions in Criterion's oeuvre, with only a short analytical essay on The Killing by film historian Haden Guest, and a very small excerpt from an interview with Marie Windsor about working with Kubrick.


The Criterion Collection fulfills a long rumored release with the essential Blu-ray of Stanley Kubrick’s The Killing, one of the great devils of 1950s American cinema.

Image 4.5 out of 5 4.5 out of 5 4.5 out of 5 4.5 out of 5 4.5 out of 5

Sound 4.5 out of 5 4.5 out of 5 4.5 out of 5 4.5 out of 5 4.5 out of 5

Extras 4.5 out of 5 4.5 out of 5 4.5 out of 5 4.5 out of 5 4.5 out of 5

Overall 4.5 out of 5 4.5 out of 5 4.5 out of 5 4.5 out of 5 4.5 out of 5

  • Blu-ray Disc
  • Dual-Layer Disc
  • Region 1
  • Aspect Ratio
  • 1.66:1 Anamorphic Widescreen
  • Dolby Digital Formats
  • English 2.0 Mono
  • DTS
  • None
  • Subtitles & Captions
  • English Closed Captions
  • Special Features
  • Stanley Kubrick’s 1955 Noir Killer’s Kiss
  • Video Appreciation of Killer’s Kiss by Critic Geoffrey O’Brien
  • Video Interview with Producer James B. Harris
  • Excerpted Interviews with Sterling Hayden from Cinema Cinemas
  • Video Interview with Poet and Author Robert Polito on Jim Thompson
  • Trailers
  • Booklet Featuring Essay by Film Historian Haden Guest and Reprinted Interview with Actress Marie Windsor
  • Buy
    Release Date
    August 16, 2011
    The Criterion Collection
    84 min
    Stanley Kubrick
    Stanley Kubrick, Jim Thompson
    Sterling Hayden, Elisha Cook, Marie Windsor, Ted DeCorsia, Joe Sawyer, Jay C. Flippen, Val Cannon, Coleen Gray, Kola Kwariani