Smoke—billowing and dispersing like cumulus clouds, swathing everything and everyone in a gorgeously opaque haze—is Le Doulos‘s expressive lifeblood. Trailing off the end of cigarettes, escaping from mouths, spilling out of a gun’s barrel, or rolling off city streets and dark waters, smoke is universal in Jean-Pierre Melville’s crime saga, his first true série noire, and one whose deliberate narrative confusion between good and bad is seductively expressed in its miasmatic atmosphere. There’s a bottomless richness to Nicolas Hayer’s cinematography, his blacks grainy and inky, the light delicately bouncing off the dark and the fog elegantly streaking across the screen. The depth of his images gives weight to that smoke, swirling around the fedora-adorned head of Jean-Paul Belmondo’s ambiguous crook Silien and his friends on both sides of the law, encasing them at once like a lover’s embrace and like a straightjacket, evoking dual sensations of escape and imprisonment. It’s smogginess to swoon over, embellishing a panorama of hardboiled double-crosses, devilish deeds and dignified sacrifices with an air heavy (literally and figuratively) with the intangible yet omnipresent presence of fate.
That mood—of destiny hovering over the damned—is paramount in Le Doulos, as Melville’s 1962 crime saga is more memorable for its storytelling than for its story. An opening tracking shot of recently paroled thief Maurice (Serge Reggiani) traversing an underpass has a shadowy splendor that establishes—in the camera’s increasing distance from its subject (until the final zoom), and in pans up to gratings that resemble prison bars—the film’s piercing fatalism. Maurice soon murders a fence and steals his jewels, has a heist interrupted by the arrival of the police, murders a detective during his getaway, and then after being picked up and sent to the Big House, begins to suspect that comrade Silien was the cops’ informant. It’s a basic setup in theory, yet one that Melville (adapting from a story by Pierre Lesou) drenches in Big Sleep-esque misdirections, reversals and red herrings, his serpentine scripting employing propulsive momentum as compensation for the impenetrability of characters’ true allegiances and relationships. The director makes motivations enigmatic while using brisk compositions and modulated rhythms to keep plot particulars lucid and riveting, a strategy in which the “what” is unmistakable but the “why” remains, until the end, just out of grasp.
Equally adept at staging a bracing heist sequence as well as a chess-match interrogation of Silien by desperate cops (the latter shot in a magnificently sustained, constantly rotating eight-minute single take), Melville effortlessly melds European existential hipness with both roughneck American genre iconocography—epitomized by the peerlessly cool Belmondo’s Bogart-y trenchcoat and hat—and melancholic, lurid jazz. The result is poeticism of a stark, romantically despondent sort, a mesmerizing marriage of old-school Hollywood grit and New-Wave dynamism electrified by Belmondo’s inscrutable, incessantly charming hood. Melville’s creeping shadows, punctuated by sharp rays of light, are menacing and entrancing, exhibiting a hyper-real loveliness that further amplifies the dreamlike nature of every reality-redefining revelation.
Le Doulos roots itself in traditional noir themes of providence, of loyalty and betrayal, of male codes of honor, and ultimately of man’s inability to escape his lot in life (“In this business, you either end up a bum or full of lead,” growls Silien). In this romantically gloomy environment, no one gets out alive, which, perhaps, is why Melville’s doomed protagonists so often encase themselves in their cigarettes’ hazy fog: They instinctively know that, confronted by fate’s immutable design, you may as well smoke ‘em while you got ‘em.
Melville's hazy blacks are magnificently reproduced by Criterion's anamorphic widescreen transfer, which is so good-excellent contrast, sharpness and film grain, and almost no edge enhancement-that it's pure nitpicking to point out that a select few scenes are a tad weathered and soft. In comparison to prior craptastic VHS releases, this disc's image clarity is something close to heavenly. A superlative job on the video is matched by a predictably serviceable but unexceptional mono audio track, which gets the job done without fuss.
A scene-by-scene audio commentary with Ginette Vincendeau, author of Jean-Pierre Melville: An American in Paris, singles out three scenes for critical discussion. Vincendeau's analysis is sharp, making one wish her comments had been extended to the rest of the film. Otherwise, the disc is an interviews-only affair. New, separate chats with directors Volker Schlöndorff and Bertrand Tavernier (who worked on the film as an assistant director and publicity agent, respectively) cover the filmmakers' respective experiences working with Melville. Two French TV interviews from 1963-one with Melville and Jean-Paul Belmondo, the other with Serge Reggiani-are interesting but fluffy, while a 1970 television chat finds Reggiani thanking Melville for his role in the film during a time in which his career had hit the skids. A trailer and new booklet essay by critic Glenn Kenny round out the package.
Le Doulos proves it: No one rocks the trenchcoat and fedora-or beats a snitching woman cuffed to a radiator-quite like Jean-Paul Belmondo.