Review: Hermanas

Director Julia Solomonoff’s more easily assimilates to America than her characters.

Hermanas
Photo: Cinema Tropical

Director Julia Solomonoff’s more easily assimilates to America than her characters, predictably conveying ’80s-era Texas using mundane, head-on angles to match the ridiculous lifestyle of shoulder pads and poofy couches. In style and subtext, there seems to be a little bit of Sweetie in this story of two sisters who reunite in the deepest heart of Reagan country in 1984 for the first time in nine years, except Solomonoff’s vision does not deconstruct or subvert narrative conventions. Elena (Valerie Bertucelli), living in exile in Spain, visits her sister, Natalia (Ingrid Rubio), in Walnut Creek, where the skeletons in their closet begin to rattle after a page is ripped from one their deceased father’s manuscripts, which may explain why Elena’s militant boyfriend disappeared many years ago.

Solomonoff strikes less interesting contrasts between past and present than her actresses, as Rubio and Bertucelli express how resentment eats away at their characters’ sisterhood so richly that the many flashbacks to Argentina, uninterestingly shot in hand-held, seem almost unnecessary. Better than these soap-operatic flashbacks, familiar slogs through Cautiva terrain, are the story’s playful, unpretentious observations of culture clash and assimilation: like Elena selling her political agenda at a dinner party in her honor and Natalia’s nervous attempts to speak English to her son’s teacher, an indiscretion the sisters laugh off but one that tellingly embarrasses little Tomas (Milton De La Canal). These fine actresses risk a natural form of human messiness that Solomonoff’s obsessively neat storytelling does not.

Score: 
 Cast: Valerie Bertucelli, Ingrid Rubio, Adrián Navarro, Nicolas Pauls, Milton De La Canal, Horacio Peña, Mónica Galán, Eusebio Poncela  Director: Julia Solomonoff  Screenwriter: Julia Solomonoff  Distributor: Cinema Tropical  Running Time: 100 min  Rating: NR  Year: 2005  Buy: Video

Ed Gonzalez

Ed Gonzalez is the co-founder of Slant Magazine. A member of the New York Film Critics Circle, his writing has appeared in The Village Voice, The Los Angeles Times, and other publications.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.