Review: Ron Clements and John Musker’s Aladdin on Disney DVD

This DVD will not disappoint purists concerned that Disney might once again remaster one of their films from a newly updated version.

AladdinAmong the more overpraised cartoons in the Disney canon, Aladdin explores what happens when a street urchin simultaneously falls in love with a princess and incurs the wrath of the evil sorcerer trying to destroy her father’s kingdom. Jasmine is another “free-spirited” type in the studio’s Barbie-doll tradition, a sexualized faux feminist who wants everyone to know that she can do everything that boys can. Though the film’s milieu is ostensibly an Arab enchanted city, there’s nothing particularly Middle Eastern about the whole thing outside of the preponderance of sand. Having spent considerable quality time with Aladdin dodging officers and fruit sellers at the local market, it’s amazing Jasmine can’t recognize Aladdin beneath the turban. It’s not like the animators have made it difficult for her, as every Arab male in the film is shady and sniveling (even the evil Jafar’s pet parrot gets his name from Shakespeare’s “darkest” play, Othello), whereas Aladdin looks like Scott Wolf and sounds like Clay Aiken. Disney knows how to sell lies, but Aladdin is ultimately less offensive than ridiculous, mostly because its ethnic white noise is really just an excuse for Robin Williams—as a postmodern blabbermouthed genie who grants Aladdin three wishes—to put on an elaborately narcissistic circus act. The actor once said, “Cocaine is God’s way of saying you’re making too much money.” Aladdin is proof that he was right.

Image/Sound

Aladdin looks great, but not as good as The Lion King did on the two-disc DVD edition of the 1994 film Disney released last year. But because Aladdin wasn’t re-released in theaters like The Lion King was prior to its video release, this DVD edition will not disappoint purists concerned that Disney might once again remaster one of their films from a newly updated version. With no deleted scenes or songs reincorporated into the mix, this is the Aladdin everyone saw back in 1992. Save for some noticeable edge enhancement, this is an absolutely pristine transfer. Even better is the aggressive and all-consuming Dolby Digital 5.1 “Disney Enhanced Home Theater Mix.” The film has certainly never sounded as good as it does here.

Extras

Disc one offers up four deleted songs (“Proud of Your Boy,” “You Can Count On Me,” “Humiliate the Boy,” and “Why Me?”), two deleted scenes (in one, Aladdin steals money from a swindler, which is apparently is more acceptable than stealing money from someone who makes an honest living), Disney song selections for anyone who wants to jump straight to the show tunes, a pop-up fun facts feature, two commentary tracks (one by the filmmakers, the second by the animators), and three music videos (“Proud of Your Boy” by Clay Aiken, “A Whole New World” by Nick Lachey and Jessica Simpson, and the original video of “A Whole New World” by Regina Belle and Peabo Bryson) with accompanying making-of featurettes. Disc two offers up numerous features (“A Diamond in the Rough: The Making of Aladdin,” “Alan Menken: Musical Renaissance Man,” and “The Art of Aladdin”) that play better than the commentary tracks on the first disc, a series of 3D games, and publicity goodies.

Advertisement

Overall

If you’re addicted to cocaine, you don’t want to miss Robin Williams’s shrill performance in this 1992 Disney monstrosity. It’s a great deterrent.

Score: 
 Cast: Scott Weinger, Robin Williams, Linda Larkin, Jonathan Freeman, Frank Welker, Gilbert Gottfried, Douglas Seale, Bruce Adler, Brad Kane, Lea Salonga  Director: Ron Clements, John Musker  Screenwriter: Ron Clements, Ted Elliott, John Musker, Terry Rossio  Distributor: Buena Vista Home Entertainment  Running Time: 90 min  Rating: G  Year: 1992  Release Date: October 5, 2004  Buy: Video, Soundtrack

Ed Gonzalez

Ed Gonzalez is the co-founder of Slant Magazine. A member of the New York Film Critics Circle, his writing has appeared in The Village Voice, The Los Angeles Times, and other publications.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.