Slant Magazine
advertisement
Search Site

Poll
Newsletter

Meeting of the Mindless

By: Sal Cinquemani On: 08/02/2009 14:00:32 In: Politics Comments: 4

Michelle Malkin

The Republican Party is so bankrupt of new ideas that they've taken to co-opting every criticism that was launched at the Bush administration for eight long years and lobbed them right back at Barack Obama. The Grand Old Party hasn't even bothered to give it the good old college try by paraphrasing their stolen ideas or disguising them with little mustaches. Just find "Bush" and replace-all with "Obama" and you've got the party's current talking points.

According to the right, the "corrupt" Obama administration is attempting a "power grab" that is "fundamentally transforming" the country and "dismantling the Constitution." Corruption isn't partisan, of course, and the new administration deserves as much scrutiny as its predecessor when it comes to presidential powers and constitutionality, but most disturbing and transparent is how the left's claims that Bush's presidency was illegitimate has been countered by a small but increasing—and increasingly vocal—fringe faction of the Republican party who claim that Obama isn't an American citizen and therefore isn't eligible to be president. After getting all the ratings mileage out of bashing Mexicans that he could, even CNN's Lou Dobbs has taken his xenophobia to a new level of parody, giving the Birthers a mainstream platform—and credibility—they hadn't enjoyed previously.

On his show earlier this week, FOX News loon Glenn Beck played a snippet of a speech in which Obama vowed to push Americans to make sacrifices for the greater good and take responsibility for things like climate change (specifically making the point that the U.S. cannot credibly demand developing nations to take steps toward more eco-friendly policies if we do not set an example), and then erupted into a predictably childish rant, the essence of which was basically "You're not the boss of me! I do what I want!" He then, fittingly, introduced blogger Michelle Malkin. Malkin is promoting her new book, Culture of Corruption: Obama and His Team of Tax Cheats, Crooks, and Cronies, which details corruption that is ostensibly so potent and pervasive that it warranted a book being released six months into Obama's first term, which is probably about as long as it took its coherence-challenged author to write it.

On the show, Malkin struggled to compose her ostensibly planned string of unintelligible buzz words and fear-mongering, warning of "shadow governments," "the Chicago way," "a civilian core," and—my favorite—"a brigade of foot soldiers implanted in neighborhoods across the city who are at the beck and call of Team Obama, um, to, whether it's shaking down banks, forming a housing entitlement mob, um, fostering voter fraud and, uh, census shenanigans." Brigade! Foot soldiers! Implanted! Shaking down! Mob! Fraud! Shenanigans! At least she didn't use the word "gang." Later in the segment, without an ounce of irony, she chirped, "Sunlight is the best disinfectant!"

Beck, in an attempt to plug Malkin's book, provided evidence to his previous claims that he's not a real reporter by declaring that he doesn't "read other people's books when it comes to their political thoughts, et cetera, et cetera." The state of the Republican Party, ladies and gentlemen:



Comments

 
By: Tray On: 08/04/2009 22:28:40
You're pretty good on movies - the only two critics I read, or collectives of critics, are you and Reverse Shot - but on politics you're just hacks. There are a ton of dumb conservatives out there, or rather dumb people masquerading as conservatives, as reflexive hatred of government spending and Democratic politicians doesn't really amount to an ideology. And that's a shame, particularly as a number of them are quite prominent figures, like Palin or Malkin or Beck. There are also a number of really dumb liberals out there, like Olbermann and Joan Walsh and Ed Schultz and a great many members of the House Democratic caucus. On the right, you currently see a lot of harebrained arguments against Obama's policies; on the left, you currently see a lot of harebrained arguments in favor of Obama's policies. Neither side has a monopoly on stupidity; in fact, any kind of serious intellect on either side, particularly on cable TV, where, for whatever reason, you choose to focus your analysis, is quite rare. That being the case, this insipid game where we make fun of each other's mental midgets is pointless and ultimately poisonous to our political discourse; it's ultimately just a series of spurious argumenta ad homines. "There are some idiots in your party; hence, my party is in the right If Palin were still running for office or stood a serious chance of becoming the GOP's nominee, if Malkin were actually a source of policy ideas on the Hill, I could see the point. But this is not the case; a Malkin (or a Joan Walsh) caters to a preexisting audience of idiots, people who would think their stupid paranoid racist thoughts, or their stupid kneejerk liberal thoughts, whether or not their talk show host of choice existed. All that a Malkin or Olbermann is symptomatic of to me is that a great many Americans on either side of the partisan divide aren't very bright - not of the intellectual decrepitude of either of the parties as a whole.
 
By: NL On: 08/07/2009 18:41:55
Thank you, Tray. You have basically voiced my opinion, directly. As far as right-winged people go, there are plenty of nuts who have made a joke of contemporary issues by refusing to support issues like stem-cell research, any form of abortion, birth control, etc. The left-wing also has it's share of nutty people, who support lethal things like rent controls(look up: Europe, NYC, etc.), labor unions, teachers unions, bogus and incoherent foreign policy " solutions, pc "tolerance". In reality, people who desperately cling to both sides of the ideological spectrum are really foolish. For instance, although I lean to the conservative side of many issues--particularly on foreign policy--I listen to all sides of the spectrum in regards to these kind of issues. This simple concept is missing from the minds of people who often identify as " conservatives" or " liberals." Fortunately, most Americans do NOT think this way(Although Gallup polls indicate Americans are becoming more conservative despite Obama's win). Sorry for the rant, but I do agree with Tray's basic point: there are idiots on both sides of the spectrum and it is ridiculous to think that just because there are idiots on one side, that makes your side of the spectrum superior or correct or even more intelligent. Really, both sides have a few lessons they could learn.
 
By: vocalism On: 08/08/2009 16:32:45
For a "liberal" site, slant sure attracts a lot of right-wing readers... Of course there are loons on both sides of the political spectrum, but I'm sorry, the right takes the cake. Michele Malkin is NOT the equivalent of Joan Walsh and Glenn Beck is NOT the equivalent of Olbermann (Olbermann is a partisan but he's not COMPELTELY off his rocker.) Glenn Beck is certifiable.
 
By: Shaz On: 09/01/2009 10:17:20
I actually sympathize with the Conservatives. The only argument they have to prove their intellectual credentials is - "Yes, Bill O' Rile-me is unhinged - but we are not all like that" or "I am not as nutty as the other conservative you saw on Fox" which, by the way, is representative of their skewed ideology.

Having said that, let's give all Fox nutters 18 hours of TV and an unending supply of the latest artery clogging, MSG laced product. At least, they'll die early.

Leave a comment

Please complete the form below to submit a comment on this article. A valid email address is required to submit a comment though it will not be displayed on the site.

HTML has been disabled but if you wish to add any hyperlinks or text formatting you can use any of the following codes: [B]bold text[/B], [I]italic text[/I], [U]underlined text[/U], [S]strike through text[/S], [URL]http://www.yourlink.com[/URL], [URL=http://www.yourlink.com]your text[/URL]

Search Blog

RSS






Advertisement
Advertisement

Staff    Slant on Facebook    Slant on Twitter    Contact    Media Kit    Privacy Policy    Terms of Service    RSS

Copyright © 2001 - 2009 Slant Magazine